is once upon a december a christmas song

Art Scpae

4 min read

·

03-12-2024

33

0

Share

Is "Once Upon a December" a Christmas Song? A Deeper Dive into the Holiday Debate

The question of whether "Once Upon a December," the hauntingly beautiful ballad from the 1998 animated film Anastasia, qualifies as a Christmas song sparks passionate debate among music lovers. While not explicitly mentioning Christmas, the song's wintery setting, nostalgic tone, and association with a film often watched during the holiday season lead many to include it in their festive playlists. However, a closer examination reveals a more nuanced answer, one that delves into the very definition of a "Christmas song" and the emotional resonance of the music itself.

The Case for "Once Upon a December" as a Christmas Song:

The most compelling argument for classifying "Once Upon a December" as a Christmas song rests on its strong thematic and atmospheric connection to the winter holiday. The lyrics evoke a sense of childhood wonder, reminiscent of the magic associated with Christmas. Lines like, "Snowflakes fallin' on my head," and the overall feeling of a snowy, fairytale-like setting instantly conjure images commonly associated with Christmas cards, festive decorations, and the winter holidays. The song's melodic simplicity and somewhat melancholic yet hopeful tone align with the emotional spectrum often evoked by Christmas carols, encompassing feelings of nostalgia, longing, and joyful anticipation.

Furthermore, the film Anastasia itself often finds its way into holiday viewing schedules. Its blend of animation, historical fiction, and a heartwarming story contributes to its appeal as a family-friendly film enjoyed during the Christmas season. The association between the film and the holiday, albeit indirect, reinforces the perception of "Once Upon a December" as a Christmas song. The song's prominence within the film's narrative, often playing during emotionally significant moments, further strengthens this association. It becomes a soundtrack to the film's "Christmas-esque" viewing experience, embedding itself within the holiday's cultural landscape.

The song's popularity during the holiday season also plays a significant role. Its inclusion in countless Christmas playlists, radio broadcasts, and even ice-skating performances cements its place in the collective consciousness as a winter holiday staple. This widespread acceptance, fueled by audience reception and cultural adoption, lends considerable weight to the argument that "Once Upon a December" transcends its lack of explicit Christmas references and becomes, effectively, a Christmas song by virtue of its widespread association with the holiday.

Arguments Against Classifying "Once Upon a December" as a Christmas Song:

Conversely, the case against considering "Once Upon a December" a Christmas song hinges on the song's lack of explicit religious or Christmas-specific themes. Unlike traditional carols that celebrate the birth of Christ or the spirit of giving, "Once Upon a December" focuses on themes of memory, longing, and a yearning for a lost past. The song's narrative centers on Anastasia's hazy recollections of her childhood in the Russian Imperial Court, rather than the specific celebrations of Christmas.

While the setting is wintery, it's not exclusively Christmas-specific. The song could equally be set during any snowy winter day, unrelated to the Christmas holiday. The absence of explicit references to Christmas traditions, symbols, or religious connotations differentiates it from songs that unequivocally belong in the Christmas genre. Songs like "Silent Night" or "Joy to the World" explicitly reference the nativity and the Christian faith, making their association with Christmas undeniable. "Once Upon a December," on the other hand, lacks these explicit religious or culturally specific Christmas markers.

Moreover, the musical style of "Once Upon a December" differs from traditional Christmas carols. While possessing a similarly nostalgic and evocative quality, it doesn't adhere to the same musical conventions found in classic carols. The song’s melody and instrumentation lean more towards a contemporary pop ballad than a traditional Christmas carol's structure. This difference in musical style further distinguishes it from the established canon of Christmas music.

A More Nuanced Perspective: Winter Holiday Music vs. Christmas Music:

The debate ultimately highlights a broader issue: the distinction between winter holiday music and Christmas music. While Christmas music is a subset of winter holiday music, many songs evoke the spirit of winter without explicitly referencing Christmas. "Once Upon a December" falls squarely into this category. It captures the essence of a magical winter, resonating with the emotions and atmosphere often associated with the holiday season, but it doesn't necessarily belong within the strict confines of Christmas-themed music.

Therefore, classifying "Once Upon a December" depends largely on the listener's perspective and their definition of a "Christmas song." For some, its wintry atmosphere and holiday association are sufficient to include it in their festive playlists. For others, the absence of explicit Christmas themes renders it unsuitable for the category. Ultimately, the song's versatility allows it to occupy a unique space in the broader landscape of winter holiday music, appealing to audiences regardless of their strict interpretation of the "Christmas song" genre.

Conclusion:

The debate surrounding "Once Upon a December" serves as a fascinating example of how subjective genre classification can be. While the song doesn't explicitly mention Christmas, its evocative winter setting, nostalgic tone, and association with holiday viewing traditions have led to its widespread adoption as a sort of unofficial Christmas song. However, a careful consideration of its lyrical content and musical style reveals it to be a more nuanced piece of winter holiday music, appealing to a wider audience than strictly Christmas-themed songs. Ultimately, whether you consider it a Christmas song rests on your individual definition and personal interpretation of the music's inherent emotional power and cultural significance. And that’s perfectly alright. The beauty of the song lies precisely in its ability to evoke feelings of wonder and nostalgia, regardless of the specific holiday it’s associated with.